Big Mac for Big Bucks: The $18 Meal That Shocked the World

Big Mac for Big Bucks: The $18 Meal That Shocked the World

From viral tweets to stock shocks: How an overpriced burger became a financial flashpoint for McDonald’s

When a tweet showcasing a whopping $18 Big Mac meal from McDonald's took the internet by storm, it didn't just spark surprise; it ignited a fiery debate across social media platforms about fast food pricing amidst soaring inflation. For a brand synonymous with fast, affordable dining, this was uncharted territory.

The viral tweet led to rampant speculation and misinformation, with claims suggesting that Big Mac prices had doubled since the pandemic began. Prominent voices like the House Republicans’ X account amplified these assertions, adding fuel to the fire. However, factual analysis soon countered these claims. Noted economist Paul Krugman clarified that Big Mac prices have increased by about 21% since 2019, which is actually below the general inflation rate of 23% and significantly under the food inflation rate of 28%. Additionally, wages for nonsupervisory workers rose by 28%, suggesting that in terms of real wages, Big Macs are not necessarily more expensive than they were before.

In response to the turmoil, McDonald's US president Joe Erlinger addressed the issue in an open letter, stressing that the $18 Big Mac meal was an outlier, occurring at just one of the over 13,700 McDonald's locations in the U.S. Erlinger expressed concern that public perception might skew towards believing such pricing was commonplace, potentially undermining the brand's reputation for value.

Get value stock insights free.

PayPal, Disney, and Nike recently dropped 50-80%.

• Are they undervalued?

• Can they recover?

• Read Value Investor Daily to find out.

We read hundreds of value stock ideas daily and send you the best.

Subscribe with one click.

Financial Impact and Stock Performance

This social media incident occurs against a backdrop of modest financial performance by McDonald's, as reflected in its stock market activities. Over the last five years, McDonald's stock (NYSE: MCD) has seen a growth of about 28%. While this growth keeps pace with average wage increases, it lags considerably behind the S&P 500's increase of nearly 90% over the same period.

In the past year alone, McDonald's shares have seen an 8% increase, compared to a 14% rise in the S&P 500. The stock recently traded around $250, with key support and resistance levels observed at approximately $230 and $260, respectively. These figures are critical as they indicate potential turning points where significant buying or selling is expected to occur.

McDonald's quarterly earnings further elucidate the situation. The company reported a revenue of $5.9 billion in the first quarter of 2024, marking a 5% increase year-over-year but falling slightly below analyst expectations. Net income for the same period was reported at $1.8 billion, up 2% from the previous year. These figures highlight a steady but cautious growth trajectory, which mirrors investor sentiments reflected in the stock's performance.

Market Reaction and Future Outlook

The viral $18 Big Mac tweet, nearing half a million views, could be perceived as an example of the Streisand effect, where attempts to obscure information only make it more prominent. This scenario adds a layer of complexity to McDonald's marketing and investor relations strategies.

Despite the potential setbacks from this episode, McDonald's remains a powerhouse in marketing. The company has historically managed to spin narratives to its advantage, leveraging its global brand presence, iconic marketing campaigns, and product affordability. The odd placement of Erlinger's open letter on the investor relations page suggests a strategic move to communicate directly with stakeholders and reassure them of the company’s commitment to value.

As the next quarter approaches, all eyes will be on McDonald's to gauge the impact of this incident on its financial health and market position. The forthcoming earnings report will be pivotal in determining whether this price anomaly was a minor hiclip or a sign of emerging challenges that could affect the company’s long-term strategy and investor confidence. Burger enthusiasts and investors alike will be keen to see how McDonald's navigates these turbulent waters and whether it can maintain its stronghold in the competitive fast-food market.